We decided to take the kids there for the first time yesterday.
Elden and Edith each got Superman ice cream, though I'm pretty sure Edith's favorite part of the experience was the complementary pretzels you're provided with when you first arrive. A kid sized scoop/cone is only $1 and the small hot fudge sundae I got was less than $3. The carousel was off when we got there but when we requested it be turned on the staff quickly obliged. If you are local (or ever visiting the area) I highly recommend you come to this location! It's unique, affordable and delicious. Malley's doesn't even know I'm writing this post, I just love it that much. Also, if you are not local, you can buy Malley's online, including the hot fudge.